It’s Time To Pull Plug On Tax Break For Home Buyers
Posted on November 9th, 2009 in Repo Trailer Homes | Comments Off
When the credit and housing bubbles burst, lawmakers of both parties said they were surprised at the impossibly large mortgages so many homeowners had taken out.
They shouldn’t have been, not any more than the fabled Capt. Renault was “shocked, shocked” that gambling was going on in his favorite Casablanca casino. Through a never ending series of new tax breaks and subsidies, and the expansion of existing ones, Congress and successive presidents have done everything in their power to get people to take on mortgage debt.
They have allowed borrowers to deduct interest on mortgages up to a $1 million. They have set the capital gains tax rate at 0% on profits from the sale of a primary residence, up to $500,000. And they have created and nurtured Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government backed companies that dominate the mortgage industry, to expand lending to questionable borrowers, putting taxpayers at risk of multibillion dollar losses.
When all this produced a colossal housing bust, sending the economy toward free fall, Congress passed and President Obama signed a “temporary” tax credit of $8,000 for first time home buyers as part of the economic stimulus program. Now the threat of depression is gone, but with the credit set to expire on Nov. 30, the housing lobby is pushing to have it extended. Some in Congress even want to expand it to $15,000 and make it apply to all home buyers.
Ironically, though virtually all Republicans voted against the stimulus and continue to lambaste it, the biggest champion of expanding the housing program is Sen. Johnny Isakson, R-Ga., a former Realtor.
For a variety of reasons, the credit should be allowed to expire. To begin with, the housing market is starting to recover. The National Association of Realtors has reported four straight months of increased sales of existing homes. Moreover, tax credits are just another form of government spending, and the government which is running a $1.6 trillion deficit this year doesn’t have any money to spend. Extending the credit, which has already cost as much as $15 billion, would mean borrowing even more from future generations to aid today’s home buyers.
Perhaps most important, an array of influential lobbies bankers, automakers and so on will be watching to see whether Washington has the fortitude to wind down a stimulus program once it has begun to throw money at an influential industry. The housing lobby isn’t the only one salivating at the federal feeding trough.
The untold truth of housing tax breaks is that they don’t really make owning a home more affordable. That’s because markets have a way of adjusting. If the government subsidizes home buying, it increases the number of people in the market and the amount they can afford to pay, which drives up prices of existing homes.
For the home building, mortgage lending and real estate brokerage industries a potent three pronged housing lobby this means bigger profits. But for prospective new homeowners, it does relatively little.
Supporters of expanding the credit for first time buyers argue that now is no time to pull back. That is always their argument. Just as real estate agents say there is no bad time to purchase a home, for the housing lobby there is no bad time for a handout. Congress, however, shouldn’t buy it.